The gap between production and implementation of knowledge is the main reason for the suboptimal quality of health care. Page 1 of 3 how to approach a journal club presentation. We introduce this model of journal club presentation to medical residents in a smallgroup workshop early during internship and. Sourceandacknowledgements i muchofthetextofthistalkisfromrussaltmansjournal club researchtalktemplate,apowerpointpresentationwith. Journal club tips for presenters journal clubs can play a valuable part of your time in grad school. How to ace your journal club presentation bitesize bio. Journal club tips how to give a good journal club presentation. Selecting a journal club article choosing an article is the. The article should have proceeded from an actual journal club. Oct 22, 20 journal club cardiovascular outcomes in clopidogrel and ppi users slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising.
Describe the background and rationale for this study o what gap in knowledge does it intend to fill o any. Others have created successful journal clubs by explicitly linking the educational experience to questions raised in caring for patients. Presentation format for journal club answer these questions in one or two sentencesyyyyou should always use your own words. Journal club 7th august 2019 dr sama balasubramanian rpa sexual health clinical infectious diseases impact factor 9. Lance cooper and celia elliott university of illinois. Elliott if you feel compelled to provide an outline, make it content. To eliminate this gap and improve the quality of patient care, journal club jc in graduate medical education provides an opportunity for learning the skills of evidencebased medicine. Rubric for journal club oral presentation category elements. Journal club, critical appraisal, evidence based medicine.
Improving journal club presentations, or, i can present that. Sourceandacknowledgements i muchofthetextofthistalkisfromrussaltmansjournal clubresearchtalktemplate,apowerpointpresentationwith. How to present an article for journal club prs resident. Your journal club presentation department of pharmacology. Slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. The estimated anc utilization rates were approximately 80%. Theory and practicals are two essential components of pharmacy course curriculum. Check with your preceptor or colleagues about the time frame, but generally 10 to 20 minutes is a good presentation length.
Some departments have journal clubs where everyone takes turns to give a short presentation on a relevant topic or paper. Presenting an article at journal club example framework background title, journal, date of publication, authors and whether they have any significant affliations. The citation styles give below reflect acp journal club s inclusion into annals of internal medicine as of the june 2012. Improving journal club presentations, or, i can present that paper.
Journal clubs have many functions, including the provision of a forum for developing skills in critical appraisal, an essential part of being a competent clinician. A group of individuals that meet to discuss and critique research that appears in professional journals. Ask questions, if you dont understand something the speaker says. Journal club tips for presenters journal clubs can play a valuable part of your time in graduate school. Make sure you understand the experimental details 1. Journal club makeover american society of healthsystem. Get the full paper in the pdf form and circulate to all the participants. They allow faculty and students at varying stages of education to interact and discuss topics. A modified indirect method for fabricating silicone softlined complete dentures presented by dr mujtaba mds ii 1 m.
Is it a clinical trial, cohort, casecontrol, crosssectional, or caseseries. Journal club presentation a journal club discussion may occur with any number of participants, but a minimum of five participants is suggested to enable a thorough discussion. Rubric for journal club oral presentation category. For those new to the idea of presenting in a journal club setting, we present a few. Pdf the journal of effective teaching class room seminar. Tips for students leading a journal club discussion. For tips on organizing a local journal club, please see the instructional pdf provided by the editors. They promote understanding of key controversies in the field, methods and their application to specific scientific areas, and critical thinking skills.
Nevertheless, literature evaluation is a crucial tool that will enhance your knowledge base and help to educate your colleagues. Journal club cardiovascular outcomes in clopidogrel and ppi users slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. You will not know the strong and weak points of the paper until you have actually put in a lot of effort so it is prudent to choose papers that make interesting and significant claims in an area of interest to you or your mentor. We introduce this model of journal club presentation to medical residents in a smallgroup workshop early during internship and then deepen residents skills during our clinical epidemiology course in the second year. It requires quite a bit of planning and an understanding of group dynamics. The first twitter journal club was an allergy journal club run by dr. Presenting an article at journal club example framework.
Renal dosing is an everyday element of pharmacy practice, although the limited demographics of the study population may limit widespread applicability of this trial to multiple patient observations, however the findings of this trial still bring many important questions to light about the equations we use to estimate renal function, their correlation to dosage recommendations to patients, and. American medical associations ama definition of a journal club. Roles and responsibilities should be clearly defined. Two articles from each months issue have been identified as ideally suited for any journal club. Journal club tips for presenters johns hopkins bloomberg. Plan the discussion session as carefully as you will plan your presentation. Citation of material published in earlier issues should follow the guidelines published in those issues. They used twitter to document the discussion of coverage of a traditional inperson journal club. For example, if you happen to be assigned an article for hand journal club that compares union rates after ulnar shortening osteotomy with transverse versus oblique pattern, you should read up on indications, patient presentation, and relevant anatomy related to these surgical techniques, not to mention the basic science of bony healing and union. Understand the key components of a successful journal club presentation. Outline for journal club presentation emory university. Is the research question or hypothesis clearly stated. Choose your paper carefully and know clearly why you are choosing it.
Useful discussion questions focus on a small set of questions e. There are numerous books on how to give a presentation, but little advice available on how to choose a good topic or paper. Choose an interesting paper with presentable data 1. Leading a good discussion is not as easy as it looks. They promote critical thinking skills, dissemination of scientific information, and generate novel research ideas. Running a successful journal club some aims of a journal club. Journal club probiotics for treating acute infectious diarrhoea duration. Suggested questions for both articles are provided. Alternatively, you can report the results after the descriptors and research question. Apr 17, 2017 the first twitter journal club was an allergy journal club run by dr. Ten tips on how to prepare a journal club article for ebm. How to cite acp journal club acpjc how to cite annals. Delivering an effective journal club presentation amanda preston, phd scienti. The zoological journal club of michigan, for example, regularly reported its activities in the journal science see figure 1.
Pdf on oct 1, 20, p f d bowles and others published how to prepare for and present at a journal club find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. From early on, journal clubs reported their proceedings in academic journals. By wednesday of the week of your presentation, you should send me a draft of your talk and your team will meet with me to discuss my. Improving journal club presentations, or, i can present. Journal club ppt by dr madhav thakur authorstream presentation. Improving journal club presentations, or, i can present that paper in under 10 minutes fifteen years ago we sought to develop a method for teaching residents how to make lean, pithy journal club presentations. Journal club presentations by type alcohol, other drugs.
Pdf how to prepare for and present at a journal club. Also, its a good idea to make copies of your handout for everyone. Authors, institution, funding source, conflicts of interest. Journal club presentation tips university of florida. Avoid trying to cram too much into one slide ydont be a slave to your slides. Approach to presenting a clinical journal club gastroenterology. Pdf how to prepare for and present at a journal club researchgate. Participants may include peers from your office, other residents in the local area andor other members of the patient care team such as occupational therapists or. If giving some background information, stick to diagrams that give an overview or an important result from a previous paper. Do you know of any of their previous work, and has it been reliable. Residents skills are reinforced and refined throughout residency at a weekly journal club attended by 10 to 20 residents. With these 5 tips, youll be a rock star for your journal club presentation. The paper discussed need not have been published in ebm. Elliott allow at least 2 min per slide do the math.
Choose something that is relevant to the particular journal club. These tips can serve as a journal club toolbox for your practice setting or clinical rotations. Twelve tips for conducting a medical education journal club. Papers that present an important concept in a clear manner. Boston university has canceled inperson classes and moved to remote teaching and learning for the balance of the spring semester and final exams. Presentation guides journal club presentation resources. Continuing professional development keeping uptodate with the literature disseminating information on and build up debate about good practice ensuring that professional practice is evidencebased learning and practicing critical appraisal skills. We introduce this model of journal club presentation to medical residents in a small group workshop early during internship and then deepen residents skills during our clinical epidemiology course in the second year. If you continue browsing the site, you agree to the use of cookies on this website. We find that when browsing through a journal our eyes go from the title if it sounds interesting to the conclusions in the abstract.
Mycoplasma genitalum in symptomatic male urethritis macrolide use is associated with increased resistance li y, su x, le w, li s, yang z, chaisson c, et al. Be brief yuse keywords rather than long sentences 4. Jan, 2020 journal club presentation guides improving journal club presentations, or, i can present that paper in under 10 minutes schwartz md, dowell d, aperi j, kalet a. Journal club tips 1 practical tips in star ting a journ al club journal club definition. Lpch resident journal club guidelines objectives for this educational experience 1. Journal club participation is not a passive spectator sport. A template for journal club presentations, celia m. Many excellent papers are published but the data does not lend itself well to a clear presentation. Journal club questionnaires are available under educational resources on the home page an ob and a gyn article are selected each month and questions are provided to facilitate your journal club. Improving journal club presentations, or, i can present that paper in under 10 minutes. The topic should be carefully selected must be clinically relevant, recent published in the last 6 months, from journal with impact factor within the top five i. Nov 21, 2012 when choosing a paper to present, keep your audience in mind. Journal club presentations san diego state university.
Research article presented on april 23, 2016, at journal club, department of pharmacology, jss college of pharmacy, mysore, india. Bmi journal club template stanford university school of. Speak clearly, towards group participants, and slowly enough to be. Training should be provided as needed critical appraisal, presentation skills etc. Journal club presentations when presenting a scientific paper, your job is not simply to reiterate what the author said, but to make the information easily understandable to your audience. Presentations ppt, key, pdf logging in or signing up. Primary literature is the basis for clinical practice and fda drug approval. Your audience needs to understand the question, why this is an important question, the question was studied i. How to give a good presentation princeton university. Model how to use the evidence based approach to formulate a clinical question and identify an applicable journal article to answer the question 3. Rubric for journal club oral presentation category elements of a strong presentation weight % knowledge and explanation of subject matter.
1047 108 1149 1044 635 232 808 316 1416 38 988 1006 1284 1562 736 1173 1465 903 475 1528 1679 1532 546 1310 1217 465 967 914 762 1459 1673 618 909 1667 1692 1272 848 573 725 578 428 482 1311 1162 344 378